Why ESPN Tabbed Jake Retzlaff as One of the 40 Most Important College Football Players in the 2025 Season
In a crowded field of college football stars and household names, ESPN made waves by listing BYU quarterback Jake Retzlaff among its “40 Most Important Players” for the 2025 college football season. For some, the selection may seem surprising — but for those closely following the Cougars’ transition in the Big 12, it makes perfect sense.
Retzlaff, now entering his second year in the BYU system and third year of FBS football, represents more than just a starting quarterback. He symbolizes the hinge point of BYU’s success or struggle in a season where the Cougars are desperately trying to re-establish themselves as a Big 12 contender.
A Quarterback With a Chip on His Shoulder
After starting several games last season following an injury to Kedon Slovis, Retzlaff had moments of brilliance mixed with flashes of inconsistency. Yet what stood out most wasn’t the stats — it was his poise under pressure, his athleticism, and his leadership qualities.
“He plays with edge,” one ESPN analyst said. “And in a year where BYU faces a brutal conference slate, they’ll need every ounce of it.”
Retzlaff’s ability to extend plays with his legs and make tough throws on the run adds a dynamic element to BYU’s offense that has been lacking in recent years. And with a full offseason to develop under offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick’s system, the expectation is that Retzlaff could take a major leap.
The Face of BYU’s Big 12 Identity
BYU’s move to the Big 12 came with high hopes — but last season was a rude awakening. The Cougars struggled against physical defenses and lacked a true offensive identity. Retzlaff now becomes the face of their rebranding.
With a strong arm, quick release, and the confidence to challenge defenses deep, he has the tools to ignite an offense that was far too stagnant in 2024. ESPN emphasized that if BYU is to finish in the top half of the Big 12, it will be because Retzlaff not only played well — but played like one of the league’s top quarterbacks.
Leadership and Experience
One intangible that helped Retzlaff make ESPN’s list? His maturity. After a standout JUCO career at Riverside City College and two seasons in Provo, Retzlaff has developed a calm demeanor that resonates with teammates.
“Guys trust Jake,” one team insider told ESPN. “He owns the huddle. That goes a long way in close games.”
High Stakes, High Impact
BYU’s 2025 schedule is unforgiving, with early-season matchups against Utah and Oklahoma State followed by road trips to TCU and Kansas State. If Retzlaff rises to the occasion, BYU could very well find itself in the mix for a bowl game or more. If he falters, the team’s trajectory changes entirely.
That’s exactly why ESPN included him: not because he’s the flashiest, but because his performance could make or break an entire program’s season.
For BYU fans, the spotlight is now firmly on Jake Retzlaff. And if he lives up to the billing, he won’t just be one of the most important players of 2025 — he could be one of the best.
