The Next Potential Penn State Wrestling Superstar? The Biggest Question May Be: How Soon
As Penn State Wrestling continues to solidify its status as a collegiate dynasty, all eyes are already turning toward the program’s next breakout star. The pipeline in Happy Valley is stacked with elite talent, but one name is generating particular buzz: PJ Duke.
The incoming freshman has already turned heads on the national scene, recently making waves at the 2025 U.S. World Team Trials. Duke stunned fans by defeating veteran NCAA standouts, including Bryce Andonian, to secure a spot at Final X — a feat that would be impressive for a seasoned college athlete, let alone a high school senior just entering the college ranks.
What makes Duke so special? Wrestling insiders cite his unmatched poise, technical precision, and gritty determination beyond his years. He’s drawn comparisons to past Penn State greats like David Taylor and Zain Retherford, and many believe he could be the next face of the program.
Still, the biggest question isn’t whether Duke will become a star — it’s how soon.
With Penn State returning a stacked lineup and several upperclassmen competing at high weights, Cael Sanderson and his staff face a decision: redshirt Duke and let him grow quietly behind the scenes, or unleash him right away and watch him learn on the fly against NCAA competition.
Given his performance on the international stage, the temptation to start him immediately will be strong. But Sanderson has always played the long game, prioritizing development over short-term gains.
Regardless of the timing, one thing is clear: PJ Duke’s arrival signals that the Nittany Lions’ reign isn’t close to ending — it’s only getting stronger. Wrestling fans better get used to heari
