In a highly anticipated season opener for the 2025 Texas Longhorns, highly touted redshirt sophomore quarterback Arch Manning failed to meet expectations, leading his No. 1–ranked squad to a disappointing 14–7 road loss against No. 3 Ohio State. Manning’s final stat line sums up the frustration: 17 of 30 passing attempts for 170 yards, one touchdown, and one interception, with a pedestrian 38 rushing yards—hardly the breakout debut many projected .
Manning’s debut was defined by inefficiency and unforced errors. Early on, he struggled with timing and accuracy, missing easy throws and failing to capitalize in the red zone; Texas went 0-for-2 inside the 20, a blemish particularly alarming given their 2024 ranking near the bottom nationally in red zone scoring . His most glaring mistake was a third-quarter interception under pressure—“I forced it,” Manning later admitted—acknowledging his own responsibility for turning the game away .
Texas’s staunch defense, though, was the slightest silver lining. The unit stifled Ohio State, holding them to just 203 total yards, including minimal rushing production and several stops on fourth down . But the offense’s inconsistency—particularly at key moments—was the story of the night.
Head coach Steve Sarkisian decried the “out-of-control” hype surrounding his quarterback, urging patience and reminding fans that this was only “one chapter” in a long season . ESPN’s coverage echoed the sentiment: inconsistent performance, media-burdened expectations, but room to grow .
Some analysts framed it as “growing pains.” As ESPN’s Heather Dinich reported, Manning was especially ineffective early, but showed improvement in the second half—completing four of seven passes for 105 yards and a touchdown in the final frame, hinting at the potential beneath the performance .
Sports Illustrated’s blunt headline—“Arch Manning Fails to Deliver in No. 1 Texas’s Loss”—captured the frustration succinctly. The article noted that Manning’s performance turned what should’ve been a coronation into a sobering debut, likening the reality to hearing chants of “overrated” echo across the stadium . Still, it acknowledged that this one poor outing doesn’t derail Texas’s goals of conference dominance or a College Football Playoff push.
A few voices offered context and forgiveness. Paul Finebaum emphasized that this misstep shouldn’t define the season, citing Manning’s pedigree and growth potential while pointing at Ohio State’s elite defensive coordination for neutralizing him .
Manning himself was unflinchingly candid in the aftermath: “Ultimately, not good enough… that starts with me.” He declined to shift blame, despite injuries and offensive line challenges, reinforcing a maturity beyond his years .
—
As Texas works to regroup, all eyes will be on whether Manning can convert these early stumbles into sustained growth. This opener may have cast a shadow, but it also sets the stage for a redemption story—one waiting to be written.
