Should the Giants Trade for Brock Purdy? | Breakfast Ball Debate,The New York Giants are in a tough spot heading into the 2025 season. After a disappointing 2024 campaign, questions continue to swirl around quarterback Daniel Jones and whether he is the long-term answer. Meanwhile, backup options like Tommy DeVito and Drew Lock don’t inspire much confidence. With that in mind, should the Giants make a bold move and trade for San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy?The Case for Trading for Purdy Brock Purdy has proven to be a steady and efficient quarterback for the 49ers since taking over the starting role in late 2022. He led San Francisco to multiple deep playoff runs and has thrived in Kyle Shanahan’s system. His ability to process defenses quickly, make accurate throws, and limit turnovers makes him an attractive option for a team like the Giants that desperately needs stability at quarterback.The Giants’ offense under head coach Brian Daboll has struggled with inconsistency, largely due to poor quarterback play and injuries to key offensive pieces like Saquon Barkley (before his departure) and the offensive line. Purdy, who operates well within a structured system, could bring the level-headed decision-making the team needs.Financially, Purdy is still on his rookie contract, making him an affordable option. Trading for him would allow the Giants to spend more money improving their offensive line and receiving corps rather than overpaying for a free-agent quarterback.Additionally, the 49ers may not be fully committed to Purdy as their long-term answer. If Shanahan sees an opportunity to upgrade with a more physically gifted quarterback or if San Francisco believes in a different developmental prospect, the Giants could swoop in and make a compelling offer.The Case Against Trading for Purdy While Purdy has had success in San Francisco, much of that can be attributed to Shanahan’s quarterback-friendly system and the elite talent surrounding him. The 49ers boast one of the best offensive lines in football, a dynamic running game led by Christian McCaffrey, and an elite group of pass-catchers in Deebo Samuel, Brandon Aiyuk, and George Kittle. The Giants, by contrast, have struggled in all of these areas. If Purdy were to come to New York, he wouldn’t have the same support system, which could expose his limitations as a quarterback.Another factor to consider is cost. While Purdy is affordable now, the 49ers may demand significant draft capital in return. The Giants, who still need to rebuild several parts of their roster, may be better off keeping their draft picks and developing a quarterback through the draft rather than making a trade.Finally, there is the question of whether Purdy is truly an upgrade over Daniel Jones. While Jones has struggled with injuries and inconsistency, he has shown flashes of strong play, especially when he has protection and playmakers. Daboll and GM Joe Schoen might decide that giving Jones one more year with an improved supporting cast is a better plan than giving up assets for Purdy.Conclusion. Trading for Brock Purdy would certainly bring a level of excitement to New York, but it is not without risks. If the Giants believe Purdy can be successful outside of Shanahan’s system, they should consider making a move. However, if they are unsure whether he can elevate an offense on his own, they may be better off sticking with Jones or drafting a quarterback in 2025.
