Headline:
Rivalry Reignited: Marcus Freeman Uses James Franklin’s Comments as Fuel in Notre Dame’s CFP Triumph Over Penn State
The once-dormant rivalry between Notre Dame and Penn State roared back to life in fiery fashion this past season, culminating in a dramatic College Football Playoff semifinal showdown. While the two schools hadn’t faced off since their days of the legendary “12-Year War” that spanned the late 80s and early 90s, recent events have reignited the spark—and head coaches Marcus Freeman and James Franklin are at the heart of it.
It all began innocently enough, at least on the surface. On the eve of the Orange Bowl in January, Freeman and Franklin shared a joint appearance marked by lighthearted exchanges. Franklin, in typical charismatic form, joked about Freeman’s youthful appearance, quipping, “I mean, look at the hairline on this guy,” before casually lobbing a dig that Notre Dame “should be in a conference.” The two coaches smiled and laughed, creating a moment that, to outside observers, seemed friendly.
Behind the scenes, though, the tone was far different.
According to a report by The Athletic, Freeman did not find Franklin’s remarks amusing. In fact, he was deeply irritated—particularly by the implication that Notre Dame’s independent status was somehow inferior. Sources revealed that Freeman expressed that irritation directly to his players in the days leading up to the playoff game, telling them he was “angry” and urging them to play with that same edge. He made it personal—and his team responded.
Notre Dame went on to defeat Penn State in a statement performance that many now view as the true relaunch of one of college football’s most historic rivalries. What once was mutual respect between institutions has now shifted into competitive animosity, and both fanbases seem to be fully embracing the tension.
The significance of the victory wasn’t lost on Freeman. It marked not only a major postseason milestone for the Irish but also served as a personal response to Franklin’s comments—proof that his team didn’t need conference affiliation to assert dominance on the national stage. In many ways, it was about pride. Freeman, in only his third season as head coach, showed that Notre Dame has both the talent and tenacity to go toe-to-toe with anyone.
Penn State, for its part, left the field with more questions than answers. And Franklin, despite his long tenure and reputation as a top recruiter, found himself once again on the outside looking in of college football’s elite circle.
As the dust settles on this playoff chapter, one thing is clear: the rivalry between Penn State and Notre Dame is no longer a relic of the past. It’s very much alive, fueled by ego, pride, and a new generation of coaches unafraid to speak—and play—with fire.
