As the 2024 Ohio State football season comes to a close, it’s time to reflect on the standout players who made an impact. On this episode of *Buckeye Talk*, hosts Stephen Means, Stefan Krajisnik, and Andrew Gillis dive into the roster to rank the top 20 players of the season. While some rankings were straightforward, others sparked lively debates.
### Top Players: Consensus and Debate
The discussion began with the top two players, where Jeremiah Smith and Caleb Downs emerged as clear frontrunners. Jeremiah Smith, a freshman wide receiver, had an outstanding season with over 1,000 receiving yards and 15 touchdowns, leading the Big Ten in both categories. His performance, especially in critical moments, solidified his case as one of the best in college football.
Caleb Downs, on the other hand, was a defensive powerhouse. His versatility allowed him to play multiple positions, from safety to linebacker, and his ability to make game-saving tackles was unmatched. While Smith’s offensive dominance was undeniable, Downs’ impact on defense made him a strong contender for the top spot.
### The Middle Tier: Key Contributors
The middle of the list featured players like Jack Sawyer, Donovan Jackson, and Will Howard. Jack Sawyer, a defensive end, had a breakout season with nine sacks and several impactful plays, including a crucial interception against Michigan. Donovan Jackson, an offensive lineman, showcased his versatility by playing multiple positions and anchoring the line. Will Howard, the starting quarterback, elevated his draft stock with a strong season, though his performance in the Michigan game left room for criticism.
### Rising Stars and Underrated Performers
Players like Tyleek Williams, Quin-Shan Judkins, and Cody Simon also earned spots on the list. Tyleek Williams, a defensive tackle, was a consistent force on the defensive line, while Quin-Shan Judkins, a running back, complemented Treyveon Henderson effectively. Cody Simon, a linebacker, stepped up in key moments, particularly in the postseason, proving his value to the defense.
### The Final Spots: Tough Decisions
The last few spots sparked debate, with players like Carnell Tate, Josh Fryar, and Denzel Burke vying for recognition. Carnell Tate, a wide receiver, had a solid season as the third option behind Smith and Emeka Egbuka, but his limited usage in big games raised questions. Josh Fryar, an offensive tackle, played through injuries and was a reliable presence on the line, though his performance against elite pass rushers was inconsistent. Denzel Burke, a cornerback, had a mixed season, with a standout game against Penn State but struggles against Oregon.
### Honorable Mentions
Several players just missed the cut, including Jermaine Matthews, a promising cornerback who showed flashes of brilliance, and Josh Simmons, an offensive tackle whose season was cut short by injury. While their contributions were notable, the depth of Ohio State’s roster made it difficult to include them in the top 20.
### Looking Ahead to 2025
With only a few players from this list returning next season, the 2025 roster will look vastly different. The spring practices will be crucial for identifying new leaders and evaluating emerging talent. As the Buckeyes aim to defend their national championship, the development of young players like Jeremiah Smith and Caleb Downs will be key to their success.
