1. 2025 Draft Snapshot: Utah vs. BYU
Utah Utes—Pro Talent Rising
Despite a slower 2025 draft class, Utah still boasts several players making pro headlines:
Junior Tafuna (DT), Karene Reid (LB), and Brant Kuithe (TE) were Utah’s top NFL Combine invitees—key Day 3 or priority free-agent targets .
Zemaiah Vaughn (CB), a standout cornerback who started 31 straight games, landed an undrafted free-agent deal with the Vikings .
Caleb Lohner (TE), a dual-sport Utah transfer, was drafted in the 7th round by the Broncos ($4.3 M contract) .
Jonah Elliss (Edge) continues making waves; drafted in 2024, he’s already an All-Rookie presence with five sacks .
On the horizon: rising stars like Lander Barton (LB), Caleb Lomu (OT) and Sione Vaki (Safety/Hybrid) have earned national attention as 2026 draft candidates .
Summary: Utah has 2 drafted, 1 UDFA, and 3 Combine invites in 2025—plus a deep 2026 class shaping up.
—
BYU Cougars—Steady Production, Slightly Ahead
BYU maintains a robust NFL output:
Nearly 20 former Cougars are currently active in the NFL, including stars like Fred Warner (49ers), Taysom Hill (Saints), and **Puka Nacua (Rams)** .
The 2025 draft class lacked top picks, but BYU’s NFL roster includes 2025-era contributors.
Recruitment pipeline continues for skill positions—especially tight ends and wide receivers in future classes .
Summary: BYU leads in raw NFL numbers and position variety, benefiting from historical depth and coaching consistency.
—
2. Quality vs. Quantity
Category Utah Utes BYU Cougars
NFL roster count Modest in 2025, with standout new signings Nearly 20 active players
Draft picks (2024–25) 2 draft picks + 1 UDFA, 3 Combine invites Few 2025 draftees, but high-profile alumni
Next-gen prospects (2026) Lomu, Barton, Vaki: bright early projections TE/WR pipeline loaded
Utah focuses on high-end talent emerging across defense and OL, with Combine invites and early draft picks promising future impact.
BYU shows strength in core numbers and positional pipelines, especially for skill positions, steeped in long-term development.
—
3. Game-Changing Prospects
Utah:
Lander Barton (LB) – 6’4″, Pac‑12 Defensive Freshman of the Year, pedigree and stats suggest early-round potential in 2026 .
Caleb Lomu (OT) – Freshman All‑American in 2023 and considered top tackle prospect for 2026 .
Sione Vaki (Safety/Hybrid) – Showed two‑way explosiveness; 2023’s first‑team All‑Pac‑12 on both sides .
BYU:
Jack Kelly (LB) – High-impact transfer, ranked top‑5 OLB by Mel Kiper Jr. .
Deep TE room: top recruits for 2025–26 (Harris, Goettsche, Kelleher) signal strong future .
WR depth: Chase Roberts, LaMason Waller III, plus transfer Terrance Saryon & pipeline additions .
—
4. Coaching & Program Infrastructure
Utah: Continues building under Kyle Whittingham with stable OL development (Jim Harding) and strong defensive coaching—key to player development .
BYU: Coaching continuity under Kalani Sitake and coordinators provides environment for turn‑key player development and NFL readiness .
—
5. Cultural & Intangible Boosts
BYU players often credited with maturity and character—shaped by missionary timelines, age, and faith-driven discipline . This intangible “coachability” + maturity gives BYU a developmental edge.
Utah’s rising stars bring similar intangible assets: leadership, resilience, and crossover athleticism (e.g. Lohner’s dual‑sport skill set, Vaki’s two‑way role), marking them as NFL-ready in non-quantifiable ways .
—
6. Future Outlook: 2026 and Beyond
Utah: The 2026 class is loaded—Lomu, Barton, Vaki hint at a stronger draft board. Early scouting link them to first‑round conversation. Coaching stability sets platform for elevation.
BYU: TE and receiver pipelines are deep. LB Kelly indicates defensive steps, but QB and OL depth may define next wave.
As ESPN forecasts show, Utah dropped due to a 5‑7 record and QB instability—but recruiting and talent development signal rebound later . BYU remains steady at ~11‑2, fueled by coaching continuity and elite talent retention.
—
7. Why Utah Is Gaining on BYU in NFL Pipeline
1. Elite Combine invites + draft preuves – Utah proving its developmental system isn’t just historical but current.
2. High-ceiling prospects emerging – early-round fantasy suggests long-term pipeline strength.
3. Expanding position diversity – from OL to hybrid safety, Utah is covering more positions primed for NFL transitions.
4. Improved OL and defense coaching – Harding’s OL clinic + defensive schemes rewarding modern NFL evaluation.
—
8. Key Challenges Ahead
Utah must:
Raise volume—boost NFL roster count and 2025 picks.
Secure QBs, WRs, OL in future drafts.
Capitalize on next-gen talent (Barton, Vaki, Lomu) with staying power and senior year progression.
BYU must:
Translate deep TE/WR pipeline into immediate NFL draft value.
Maintain character culture and coaching ethos in an increasingly transfer-driven environment.
—
9. Final Word: Widening the Gap
BYU holds edge in sheer numbers and position depth, but Utah’s quality-tier talent and higher draft ceilings are tilting the scales.
Utah’s steady influx of premium prospects across multiple spots—especially OL, LB, hybrid safety—suggests they’ll close the numerical gap soon.
Watching Utah pass BYU in total draft picks and 2026 selections could be the next headline.
In short: BYU leads now; Utah is rapidly accelerating. The Utes are primed to take over the pipeline mantle by 2026.
—
