Let’s just get straight to the point — Reece Walsh had a decent game. He ran hard, backed up his teammates, and did what was expected of a first-grade fullback. No more, no less. But if you’ve scrolled through social media after the match, you’d think he singlehandedly reinvented the sport of rugby league. Let’s pump the brakes for a moment and get real about what we actually saw on the field.
Walsh is an undeniably talented player. He’s electric in open space, brings flair to every touch, and has that star power that the NRL marketing team dreams about. But as a Proud Penrith Panthers supporter, I can’t help but roll my eyes at the over-the-top praise that follows his every step. The way some fans and commentators carry on, you’d think he just produced another Nathan Cleary 2023 Grand Final masterclass. Spoiler alert: he didn’t.
Yes, he was ok. He played his part in the system, linked well on the edges, and made a few crucial defensive reads. But where was the game-breaking moment? The leadership? The clutch play that changes everything? Those are the moments that separate the good players from the great ones. And as Panthers fans know all too well, greatness is defined not by highlight reels but by consistency, composure, and championship execution — three things our boys have mastered over four straight Grand Final appearances.
When you watch Penrith, you see a team built on structure, discipline, and selflessness. Every player knows their role and delivers it without the need for flash or fanfare. Dylan Edwards doesn’t need to scream for attention — he just racks up 300 metres, makes 20 carries, and outworks everyone on the field. Compare that to the hype surrounding Walsh every time he makes a line break or tosses a no-look pass. It’s the difference between showmanship and substance.
The media loves a headline, and Reece Walsh gives them plenty. But if we’re talking about genuine impact, let’s be honest — Penrith’s system players would run circles around most of the so-called “superstars” in the comp. Guys like Isaah Yeo, Liam Martin, and Brian To’o don’t rely on hype; they rely on execution. They’ve proven that you don’t need flash to dominate — just relentless effort and unbreakable chemistry.
So yeah, Walsh played his part. He did his job. But let’s not pretend it was anything more than that. He wasn’t the difference-maker, he wasn’t the general steering his team to victory — he was a cog in a system that worked well enough on the day. Nothing more, nothing less.
As a proud Panthers fan, I’ve seen what true excellence looks like. I’ve seen Cleary drag a team back from the dead in a Grand Final. I’ve seen Edwards turn defensive sets into momentum swings. I’ve seen Martin play through pain for the badge on his chest. That’s greatness.
So while everyone else is losing their minds over Walsh’s “solid” performance, I’ll stay grounded in reality — because in Penrith, being OK just isn’t good enough.
#NRLol #PantherPride #ReeceWalsh #
PenrithPanthers
