Kelly: Trading Jonnu Smith Would Signal the Dolphins Are Back to Tanking | Opinion
The Miami Dolphins made headlines when they acquired tight end Jonnu Smith during the offseason, adding a versatile weapon to their already dynamic offense. However, recent speculation about the team potentially trading Smith has stirred concern among fans and analysts alike. In the opinion of columnist Kelly, such a move would be more than just a roster shuffle—it would be a sign that the Dolphins are retreating from contention and heading back into rebuild mode.
Smith, known for his athleticism and ability to make plays after the catch, offers a unique dimension to Miami’s offense. His presence is expected to ease pressure on quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, open up the middle of the field, and complement star receivers Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle. Trading away a player of his caliber—especially before he’s even played a snap in aqua and orange—would raise serious questions about the organization’s direction.
Kelly argues that letting go of Smith could undermine team chemistry and send the wrong message to both players and fans. With the AFC East more competitive than ever, the Dolphins need every asset they can leverage to stay in the playoff hunt. Trading Smith, particularly for future draft picks, would appear less like a strategic move and more like a quiet surrender.
The Dolphins have spent the past few years shaking off their reputation as a tanking franchise. With recent playoff appearances and a more aggressive front office approach, they seemed committed to building a contender. Kelly warns that dealing Smith now could undo that progress, making it seem like Miami is once again prioritizing long-term assets over immediate success.
If the Dolphins want to prove they’re serious about winning, keeping Jonnu Smith should be a no-brainer—not a tr
ade chip.
