Is Arch Manning Worthy of Being the Heisman Trophy Favorite?
The buzz surrounding Arch Manning has been growing since his high school days, thanks in part to his legendary football lineage. Now at Texas, expectations have reached a fever pitch — but is he truly deserving of Heisman Trophy favorite status?
Manning’s talent is undeniable. He possesses elite arm strength, impressive pocket awareness, and athleticism that makes him a dual-threat option. His spring game performance hinted at major upside, showcasing his ability to command the offense and make high-level throws. If he secures the starting job and delivers early-season fireworks, his Heisman candidacy could quickly gain momentum.
However, the label of “Heisman favorite” usually goes to proven stars with on-field production — something Manning hasn’t yet delivered at the collegiate level. Other quarterbacks like Georgia’s Carson Beck, Alabama’s Jalen Milroe, and Oregon’s Dillon Gabriel bring far more experience into the 2025 season. They’ve played in big games, led their teams through tough stretches, and have the stats to back up their case.
There’s also the challenge of living up to immense hype. Manning’s surname brings attention, but it also sets the bar sky-high. While he may have the potential to dominate, the Heisman conversation demands more than potential — it requires performance, consistency, and leadership on the biggest stages.
In short, Arch Manning has the tools and the platform to enter the Heisman race — especially if Texas lives up to its playoff aspirations. But calling him the favorite before he’s taken a meaningful snap may be premature. The spotlight is his to seize, but the journey must begin with proving he’s more than a name — he’s a next-level quarterback ready
to lead.
