Insider Revealed: One BYU Coach Gives a Hint as to Who the Next Cougar Quarterback Should Be
With the 2025 college football season on the horizon, all eyes are on Brigham Young University (BYU) as it faces a crucial decision at one of the most important positions in the sport: quarterback. In a subtle yet telling moment, one BYU coach may have just dropped a major hint about who he believes should be the next starting signal-caller for the Cougars.
According to a trusted insider close to the program, the unnamed coach—described as a long-time staff member with deep ties to player development—recently made some intriguing comments during a closed-door team meeting and a subsequent media availability session. While no official depth chart has been released, his remarks have sparked widespread speculation and renewed the debate over the future of BYU football’s most high-profile position.
“When you see a guy take command of the huddle, earn the respect of the locker room, and back it up with consistent play in practice, it’s hard to ignore,” the coach said, reportedly referring to sophomore quarterback Ryder Burton.
Burton, a four-star recruit out of Springville High School, saw limited action last season but has impressed throughout spring practices and early training camp. Known for his poise, quick release, and above-average football IQ, Burton has steadily climbed the depth chart and appears to have the confidence of at least some members of the coaching staff.
While the coach stopped short of naming a starter outright, he made it clear that leadership and decision-making—both on and off the field—would weigh heavily in the final decision.
“We’re not just looking for who throws the prettiest ball or has the strongest arm,” he added. “We need someone who elevates the team—who can command the moment when everything is on the line.”
This sentiment may give Burton a significant edge over his competition, including junior Jake Retzlaff and redshirt freshman Cole Hagen, both of whom bring their own strengths but haven’t quite separated themselves during fall camp.
The coach’s comments have fueled speculation that BYU might be leaning toward giving the reins to the younger Burton, signaling a potential long-term investment at the position as the program continues to transition in the Big 12.
For head coach Kalani Sitake, the quarterback decision could have massive implications. After a tough 2024 campaign, BYU is under pressure to bounce back and prove it can consistently compete at a Power Five level. Stability and leadership at quarterback will be crucial.
Fans, for their part, seem divided. Some are excited about the prospect of Burton starting, citing his upside and maturity beyond his years. Others favor the more experienced Retzlaff, especially given BYU’s challenging early-season schedule.
Regardless of who wins the job, the decision appears imminent. And if the insider’s hint is any indication, the Cougars may be ready to turn the page and usher in a new era under center—with Ryder Burton potentially leading the charge.
