Gordon Monson: Bear Bachmeier or McCae Hillstead, Whoever Is Named BYU’s Quarterback, Will Have to Do This and Not Do That
BYU football analyst Gordon Monson has shared key insights on what the Cougars’ next starting quarterback—whether Bear Bachmeier or McCae Hillstead—will need to do to succeed this season. Monson emphasized that the quarterback position at BYU requires precision, leadership, and adaptability to thrive within the team’s offensive system.
According to Monson, the chosen QB must prioritize smart decision-making and avoid forcing risky throws that could lead to turnovers. Protecting the football and maintaining consistency in passing accuracy will be essential to keep the offense productive and support the team’s overall game plan.
Monson also highlighted the importance of command over the huddle, noting that the quarterback will need to inspire confidence in teammates and make quick, correct reads against increasingly complex defensive schemes. Leadership both on and off the field is expected to be a defining factor in BYU’s success this season.
At the same time, Monson cautioned that the QB must not rely solely on individual talent but embrace the system, leverage the skill positions effectively, and execute the playbook with discipline. Avoiding overreliance on improvisation will be critical to sustain drives and capitalize on scoring opportunities.
Both Bear Bachmeier and McCae Hillstead bring unique strengths to the role, but Monson stresses that whichever quarterback starts will need to balance aggressive playmaking with calculated control. Success will come from blending personal talent with strategic adherence to BYU’s offensive philosophy, ensuring that the Cougars can compete at a high level throughout the season.
The guidance Monson provides sets a clear blueprint for the quarterback role, emphasizing the combination of leadership, accuracy, and smart decision-making required to thrive under the bright lights of college football at BYU.
