In the 2024–25 college basketball season, ESPN’s Football Power Index (FPI) projected contrasting futures for BYU and Utah as they navigated their inaugural year in the Big 12 Conference.
BYU, under first-year head coach Kevin Young, faced skepticism from analysts, with FPI forecasting a modest 4.8 wins and a 35.4% chance of bowl eligibility. Their schedule was daunting, featuring matchups against top-tier Big 12 teams like Kansas, Kansas State, and Arizona. Despite these challenges, the Cougars defied expectations, finishing the season with a 26–10 record, including a 14–6 conference record. Their performance earned them a spot in the NCAA Tournament, where they advanced to the Sweet Sixteen.
In contrast, Utah’s men’s basketball team, led by interim coach Josh Eilert after the mid-season firing of Craig Smith, had a more tumultuous season. The Utes concluded the regular season with a 16–15 overall record and an 8–12 conference record. Their performance in the Big 12 Tournament was underwhelming, and they did not secure a berth in the NCAA Tournament.
The rivalry between BYU and Utah was reignited during the season, culminating in a thrilling game on March 8, 2025. BYU emerged victorious with an 85–74 win, marking their eighth consecutive victory. Dawson Baker led the Cougars with 15 points, while Richie Saunders added 14. Utah’s Miro Little scored 21 points, but it wasn’t enough to overcome BYU’s momentum.
These outcomes highlighted the unpredictable nature of the FPI projections and underscored the dynamic and competitive landscape of the Big 12 Conference.
