Baseball columnist Jon Heyman recently expressed that he “would like” to see third baseman Nolan Arenado join the Detroit Tigers. While this comment might be speculative, it opens up an intriguing discussion about both Arenado’s future and Detroit’s rebuilding trajectory. Could a move like this actually happen? And more importantly, would it make sense for both Arenado and the Tigers?
Nolan Arenado is one of the premier third basemen in Major League Baseball. Known for his elite defense, strong arm, and consistent offensive production, Arenado has earned numerous Gold Gloves, All-Star selections, and Silver Slugger awards. Even as he enters the later stages of his career, he remains a valuable player who could significantly boost any lineup. After being traded from the Colorado Rockies to the St. Louis Cardinals in 2021, Arenado has remained a steady presence, though the Cardinals have struggled to recapture their competitive edge.
The Detroit Tigers, on the other hand, are a team in transition. After several rebuilding seasons, the club is beginning to show signs of life. With a developing young core featuring players like Riley Greene, Spencer Torkelson, and Tarik Skubal, Detroit appears to be on the verge of becoming a legitimate contender in the AL Central. What they currently lack, however, is a veteran superstar who can lead both on and off the field—and that’s where Arenado could come in.
From a roster standpoint, adding Arenado would be a major upgrade at third base, a position that has been a revolving door for the Tigers in recent years. His defense alone would solidify the infield, and his bat would offer much-needed power and consistency in the middle of the lineup. Beyond statistics, Arenado would bring playoff experience, leadership, and a winning mentality—traits that are critical for a young team trying to take the next step.
Of course, a trade or acquisition of this magnitude comes with complications. Arenado has a no-trade clause and a sizable contract, which would require Detroit’s front office to commit significant financial resources. Additionally, the Cardinals may be reluctant to part with such a marquee player without receiving a substantial package in return. Detroit would likely need to give up some top prospects or major league-ready talent, a tough ask for a team still building for the future.
Still, there’s an argument to be made that Detroit is nearing the point where such a bold move makes sense. With the AL Central lacking a dominant powerhouse, the Tigers have an opportunity to seize the moment and accelerate their timeline. Adding Arenado would signal to fans and players alike that the team is serious about competing—not just in the future, but now.
In the end, while Heyman’s comment may have been speculative, the idea is worth entertaining. Nolan Arenado in a Tigers uniform would be exciting, impactful, and possibly transformative. Whether it happens remains to be seen, but for a franchise hungry to return to relevance, such a move could be the spark they’ve been waiting for.
