As the college football season approaches, Brigham Young University (BYU) finds itself in the midst of a critical roster crunch. With the season opener just weeks away, the Cougars’ coaching staff is facing tough decisions on which players will make the final cut. The combination of incoming transfers, returning veterans, and promising newcomers has created a highly competitive environment that is both exciting and challenging for the program.
Head coach Kalani Sitake and his staff are no strangers to managing depth charts, but this year’s roster presents unique challenges. BYU has been aggressive in the transfer portal, bringing in players with Power Five experience to bolster both offense and defense. While this has elevated the overall talent level, it has also complicated position battles. Established players now find themselves competing with new additions who bring proven skills and college-level experience. These internal battles have intensified during spring practices and fall camp, pushing every athlete to perform at their highest level.
Nowhere is the competition more apparent than at the quarterback position. With the departure of last season’s starter, the door is open for a new leader to emerge. Several candidates have stepped up, each bringing a different skill set. Coaches must decide whether to go with a dual-threat quarterback who can extend plays with his legs or a more traditional pocket passer who can control the game through precision and timing. The choice will shape the offense’s identity heading into the season.
On the defensive side, BYU is working to rebuild after an inconsistent performance last season. The front seven, in particular, is under close scrutiny. New defensive coordinator Jay Hill has made it clear that only the most physical and disciplined players will earn starting roles. This has led to a number of unexpected standouts emerging, including underclassmen who weren’t initially expected to contend for major playing time. However, this also means some veteran players may find themselves on the bubble or even looking to transfer elsewhere for opportunities.
Special teams, too, is an area where decisions loom. Reliable kickers and return specialists are crucial in close games, and BYU is weighing performance consistency against potential upside from younger players. Coaches must balance experience with explosiveness, making these calls even more nuanced.
Roster management in college football has grown increasingly complex with the rise of the transfer portal and changing NCAA eligibility rules. For BYU, the goal remains clear: field the most competitive team possible while fostering development and team chemistry. However, not every talented player can make the final roster. Some will be redshirted, others will transfer, and a few may simply fall short.
As BYU finalizes its lineup, the coaching staff’s decisions will not only affect the outcome of the season opener but could shape the entire trajectory of the season. With expectations high and fans eager for a strong start, the pressure is on. The Cougars must make every roster spot count.
