As the 2025 college football season looms, BYU Football finds itself at a pivotal crossroads—navigating the rugged terrain of Power Five competition in the Big 12 Conference while wrestling with internal growing pains and identity questions. The Cougars, once kings of independence, now face the sobering reality of weekly slugfests against faster, deeper, and better-funded opponents.
Last season’s 5–7 finish—marked by flashes of brilliance but marred by inconsistency—told the story. The offense, which once thrived under former quarterback Jaren Hall, sputtered under an unsettled rotation. The arrival of sophomore signal-caller Cade Katoa, a dual-threat with raw talent but limited experience, has sparked both hope and uncertainty in Provo. His chemistry with returning standout wide receiver Keanu Hill could be the ignition point BYU desperately needs, but protection issues persist. The offensive line, rebuilt after the departure of three senior starters, struggled in spring scrimmages, giving up 11 sacks across two sessions.
Defensively, coordinator Jay Hill has implemented an aggressive 4–2–5 scheme, designed to combat the speed-heavy offenses of the Big 12. Yet, the Cougars’ defense ranked 10th in the conference last year, plagued by missed tackles and a lack of pressure. A bright spot comes in junior linebacker Logan Lutui, a relentless sideline-to-sideline defender who led the team in tackles and has embraced the role of vocal leader in the locker room.
Recruiting remains a long-term concern. While the Cougars have tapped into their traditional LDS pipeline, the depth chart lacks the kind of four-star talent their rivals boast. Head coach Kalani Sitake, now in his ninth season, acknowledges the challenge but remains optimistic. “We’re building—not just to compete, but to win championships. It’ll take time, but the culture is strong,” he said during media day.
Still, fans are restless. Lavell Edwards Stadium, once a bastion of autumn dominance, has seen declining attendance and rising frustration. With road games at Texas Tech, Kansas State, and Oklahoma State looming, BYU faces a gauntlet that could define—or derail—their season.
The transition to the Big 12 was never meant to be easy. But in the face of mounting pressure and transition turbulence, BYU’s resilience—and perhaps its very identity—will be put to the ultimate test in 2025.
