BREAKING: Bronco Mendenhall, Former BYU Head Coach, Now Bench Coach in New York, Sends Message to Kalani Sitake
In a surprising and headline-grabbing development, former BYU head coach Bronco Mendenhall has re-emerged on the football scene, this time in an unexpected role—as a bench coach for a professional team in New York. While many fans have been speculating on his next move since stepping down as head coach at the University of Virginia in 2021, few predicted a return in this capacity or in this location.
Even more intriguing is the message Mendenhall reportedly sent to current BYU head coach Kalani Sitake. Though details of the communication remain undisclosed, the news has stirred conversation among fans, analysts, and former players alike. Given the shared history between the two coaches and the current trajectory of BYU’s football program, the message raises questions about mentorship, concern, and possibly even advice or critique.
Bronco Mendenhall served as BYU’s head coach from 2005 to 2015, leading the Cougars through a decade of consistent winning seasons, bowl appearances, and a strong defensive identity. When he left for Virginia, it marked the end of an era, and the torch was passed to Kalani Sitake, a former BYU fullback and defensive coordinator at Utah. Sitake’s tenure has been marked by both challenges and successes, including the program’s recent move to the Big 12 Conference.
The timing of Mendenhall’s message is particularly notable, as BYU navigates the heightened competition and visibility that comes with Power Five conference membership. Some speculate that Mendenhall’s message could be a gesture of support—perhaps offering guidance as Sitake leads the Cougars through this new chapter. Others wonder if it might be a more sobering communication, reflecting concern about the team’s direction or recent performances.
Mendenhall’s new role as a bench coach in New York also raises eyebrows. It’s unusual to see a former head coach of his stature step into a supporting role, especially after years away from the game. This move could signal a desire to re-enter coaching in a less demanding capacity, or it may be part of a longer-term plan to stay connected to the game while evaluating future head coaching opportunities.
Fans of both BYU and Mendenhall will be watching closely to see if more details about the message emerge, and whether it signals any kind of deeper involvement or potential return to the college football landscape. As for Sitake, he remains at the helm of a program with passionate support and high expectations. Navigating the Big 12 is no easy task, and any advice or perspective from a veteran like Mendenhall—whether welcome or unsolicited—could play a role in shaping BYU’s path forward.
For now, all eyes remain on Provo and New York as this surprising connection between two Cougar coaches continues to unfold.
