Big 12 Confirms Controversial Holding Call in BYU’s Comeback Win Over Utah
The Big 12 Conference has officially confirmed a controversial holding call made during BYU’s dramatic comeback win over the University of Utah, reigniting fierce debate among fans, analysts, and coaches. The ruling in question occurred late in the fourth quarter during a pivotal drive that allowed BYU to continue its momentum and ultimately seal a comeback victory in one of the most heated rivalries in college football—the “Holy War.”
The disputed call took place with just over two minutes remaining in the game. Utah’s defense appeared to have stopped BYU on third down, which would have forced a punt and potentially given the Utes a final opportunity to run down the clock. However, a flag was thrown for holding against a Utah defensive lineman, granting BYU a fresh set of downs. The Cougars capitalized on the opportunity, scoring the game-winning touchdown moments later.
Following widespread criticism and scrutiny from fans and media, the Big 12 released a statement confirming that the call was reviewed internally and deemed correct according to conference officiating standards. “After thorough review, the holding penalty called on the play in question was consistent with the rules and interpretations used throughout the season,” the statement read. “Our officials are held to the highest standards, and this call aligns with those expectations.”
Despite the confirmation, the reaction from the college football community has been polarized. Utah fans and some former players have expressed frustration, arguing that the call was too ticky-tack for such a critical moment in the game. On social media, video clips of the play circulated rapidly, with many claiming there was minimal contact that didn’t appear to affect the play’s outcome.
BYU head coach Kalani Sitake stood by the officiating. “We play tough football, and we respect the officials and their judgment,” Sitake said in a post-game press conference. “We earned that win, and we made the plays when it counted.”
On the other hand, Utah head coach Kyle Whittingham was visibly frustrated. “You want the players to decide the game in a rivalry like this, not a borderline call,” he said. While careful not to openly criticize the officials, Whittingham made clear his belief that the call dramatically influenced the game’s outcome.
The confirmation from the Big 12 has done little to cool the controversy, and the game is now likely to be remembered not just for BYU’s comeback but for the officiating decision that made it possible. Rivalries like BYU vs. Utah are already charged with emotion, and a moment like this only adds fuel to the fire.
The aftermath of the game has also sparked renewed discussion about how officiating is handled in high-stakes matchups and whether college football should explore more transparency or changes in how calls are reviewed. As it stands, the Big 12 is standing firmly by its officiating crew, and BYU moves forward with a signature win—albeit one shadowed by controversy.
