As BYU steps into its second season in the Big 12 Conference, questions continue to swirl around the quarterback position.

As BYU steps into its second season in the Big 12 Conference, questions continue to swirl around the quarterback position.

Head coach Kalani Sitake has acknowledged the outside skepticism, with analysts pointing to uncertainty under center as the Cougars’ biggest obstacle. Yet, even as expectations are being tempered by critics, Sitake is holding firm to his vision—and his hopes remain high.

 

The cautious tone is understandable. The Cougars struggled with consistency at quarterback last season, and this year’s competition remains wide open, with players like Jake Retzlaff vying to prove themselves worthy of the starting role. That unsettled picture has many wondering if BYU can truly keep pace with conference heavyweights.

 

But Sitake has a different perspective. Rather than viewing the competition as a liability, he sees it as an opportunity for growth, toughness, and resilience. He has repeatedly emphasized that his program thrives on player development, and he’s betting on that culture to pay off in 2025. For him, the uncertainty isn’t a problem—it’s a chance for leaders to rise and define the team’s identity.

 

“People can doubt us, and that’s fine,” Sitake suggested recently. “What matters is what happens on the field.” His words echo a quiet confidence that the Cougars may surprise, especially with an offensive line that’s maturing and a defense expected to be more aggressive this year.

 

While the national outlook might have BYU pegged as a middle-of-the-pack Big 12 squad, Sitake is building his group around belief, hard work, and the element of surprise. The skepticism may lower expectations, but in Provo, the hope burns higher than ever.

 

This season, the Cougars aren’t chasing the hype—they’re chasing respect. And Sitake believes that will make all the difference.