An NFL analyst has sparked debate by labeling Kyler Murray’s contract as the worst deal in Arizona Cardinals history. The scathing critique comes amid continued questions about Murray’s long-term value and the franchise’s direction. Signed in 2022, Murray’s five-year, $230.5 million extension included $160 million in guarantees — a commitment that now appears questionable given his recent struggles and injury history.
At the time of the deal, the Cardinals believed they were locking down their franchise quarterback for the foreseeable future. Murray had shown flashes of brilliance, earning Pro Bowl honors and leading Arizona to the playoffs in 2021. However, his performance since then has been inconsistent, and a torn ACL late in the 2022 season significantly derailed his trajectory. Even upon returning in 2023, Murray was unable to recapture his earlier form, raising concerns about his ability to lead the team under new head coach Jonathan Gannon.
The analyst didn’t hold back, citing the massive cap hit, limited trade flexibility, and lingering questions about Murray’s leadership and durability. The contract also reportedly caused tension within the organization, especially after a controversial “independent study clause” was initially included, questioning Murray’s preparation habits.
With the Cardinals owning the No. 4 overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft and investing in a long-term rebuild, speculation has grown about whether the team might eventually move on from Murray. But the financial constraints of his deal make any quick exit unlikely.
While Murray still has time to turn things around, the criticism of his contract highlights the risks of paying big money for potential rather than sustained success. Unless he bounces back soon, the Cardinals may be forced to live with the fallout of what’s increasingly viewed as a regrettable
gamble.
