Analyst Says Texas Tech’s Joey McGuire is a Better Coach Than Dave Aranda, But What Has He Done?
In the ever-evolving world of college football coaching, few statements can stir as much debate as the claim that Texas Tech’s Joey McGuire is a better coach than Baylor’s Dave Aranda. While both coaches have impressive resumes and have made significant strides in their respective programs, the assertion that McGuire outshines Aranda raises several questions: What has McGuire actually accomplished? How does his track record compare to Aranda’s? And, more importantly, can this comparison truly be substantiated?
The Rise of Joey McGuire
Joey McGuire’s coaching career has certainly been a rapid ascent. Before becoming the head coach at Texas Tech in 2021, McGuire was widely respected for his success as the associate head coach at Baylor, where he helped build a strong defense and contributed to the team’s resurgence under Matt Rhule. McGuire’s reputation as a recruiter, motivator, and leader grew during his time at Baylor, where he was pivotal in revitalizing a struggling program.
As Texas Tech’s head coach, McGuire’s impact has been immediate. Despite inheriting a program that had not been a consistent contender in the Big 12 for several years, McGuire quickly injected energy and passion into the Red Raiders. Under his leadership, Texas Tech showed notable improvement, including a key victory over Oklahoma in 2022, signaling that McGuire could indeed be the catalyst to return Texas Tech to relevance in the Big 12.
McGuire’s coaching philosophy is rooted in toughness, discipline, and high-energy football, all qualities that have resonated well with the Texas Tech fanbase. He is a hands-on coach who understands the importance of establishing a strong team culture, and his recruiting prowess has already led to key commitments from high-profile players. Though his tenure is still in its early stages, McGuire’s track record in a short time is noteworthy.
Dave Aranda’s Solid Foundation at Baylor
On the other hand, Dave Aranda’s success at Baylor has been undeniable. After taking over as head coach in 2020, Aranda inherited a program that was in disarray following the departure of Matt Rhule, but he immediately demonstrated his acumen by leading the Bears to a Big 12 Championship in just his second year. His defensive-minded approach has transformed Baylor into one of the most formidable teams in the conference.
Aranda’s success at Baylor has been built on consistency and a solid foundation. His teams are known for their disciplined play, particularly on defense, where they rank among the best in the country. Aranda’s ability to turn around the program so quickly, paired with his calm demeanor and sharp football mind, has earned him respect across the college football landscape.
In addition to the Big 12 title, Aranda has shown that he can develop players and build sustainable success, a key hallmark for any head coach. While he has yet to have the kind of sustained success McGuire may aim for, Aranda’s record thus far certainly puts him in an elite class of Big 12 coaches.
The Comparison: McGuire vs. Aranda
The comparison between McGuire and Aranda is difficult to justify when considering the difference in experience and accomplishments. McGuire’s program at Texas Tech is still very much in a phase of rebuilding, and while there have been flashes of success, the Red Raiders haven’t yet matched the consistency that Aranda has cultivated at Baylor.
That said, McGuire’s potential is undeniable. His enthusiasm, recruiting ability, and vision for the future of Texas Tech are qualities that could ultimately make him a highly successful coach. However, to say he is already a “better” coach than Dave Aranda is premature.
Aranda has already delivered a Big 12 Championship and proven his ability to compete at the highest level in a Power Five conference. McGuire, on the other hand, has yet to secure the same level of tangible success. While McGuire has made strides, it would be wise to give him more time to develop his program fully before making comparisons to a coach who has already demonstrated consistent success on the big stage.
Conclusion
While Joey McGuire may be a rising star in college football coaching, the claim that he is a better coach than Dave Aranda is, for now, more speculative than substantiated. McGuire has shown promise, but Aranda’s proven track record, including a Big 12 Championship and consistent top-tier defense, places him in a different category at this point. Only time will tell whether McGuire can take Texas Tech to similar heights, but for now, Aranda remains the more accomplished coach in the Big 12.
