In a fresh analysis of the Associated Press poll history, sports reporter Brett McMurphy of On3 has declared BYU football the most underrated program in the country since 2014 . This designation isn’t just a label—it’s a validation of the frustration and pride simmering within Cougar Nation for years. Despite modest expectations, projections that underestimated their potential, and being regularly snubbed in preseason hype (be it media polls or national discussions), BYU rose above the noise to prove doubters wrong.
Rewinding to 2024, the Cougars were pegged to finish 13th out of 16 in their debut Big 12 preseason media poll—a clear indicator of the lack of respect afforded to the team . Yet, led by coach Kalani Sitake, BYU delivered an 11–2 record, tied for first in the conference, and capped the season with a 36–14 blowout win in the Alamo Bowl . They closed the year ranked #13 in the final AP Poll and #14 in the Coaches Poll—their best showing in years .
That the team was consistently overlooked before the season yet managed to shatter expectations fits neatly with McMurphy’s “most underrated” tag. The Cougars didn’t just outperform projections—they dominated the narrative, redefining what many thought possible in Provo.
The data and the storylines align: a program disregarded in preseason assessments, especially after a struggling 5–7 first year in the Big 12 in 2023 , transformed into a league-leading force in just one year. McMurphy’s analysis gives voice to Cougar fans who have long felt that their team’s resilience, identity, and legacy—rooted in a “quarterback factory” tradition and a national brand—were never given their due .
More than just wins and rankings, BYU delivered statement moments—like routing No. 13 Kansas State 38–9 and winning through all three phases: offense, defense, and special teams . Their renewed national visibility was reflected in increased media coverage, top-tier broadcast slots, and an electric home atmosphere that demanded attention . All of this further reinforces the sense that the Cougars have long been underrated—and are finally being seen for who they are.
In short, the report doesn’t just confirm a statistical curiosity—it gives Cougar fans long feeling dismissed a tangible reason to celebrate. BYU was once written off. Now, the rest of the nation is rushing to catch up.
—
This brings BYU fans the acknowledgment they’ve long deserved—and the broader college football world a compelling story of perseverance and resurgence.
