History Repeating? Finebaum Says Alabama’s Recruiting Feels Like Peak Saban
TUSCALOOSA, Ala. — For college football fans, the words “Peak Saban” carry a certain mythos — a time when Alabama didn’t just recruit well, it recruited historically. From Julio Jones to Tua Tagovailoa, the Crimson Tide were the undisputed kings of signing day for over a decade. Now, ESPN analyst Paul Finebaum is raising eyebrows with a bold claim: Alabama’s current recruiting momentum under head coach Kalen DeBoer is beginning to feel like that golden era all over again.
“This is starting to smell like 2011,” Finebaum said during a recent segment on College Football Live. “It’s early, but the aggression, the consistency, and the talent they’re pulling — this has all the signs of another dynastic foundation.”
After a transitional 2024 campaign under first-year head coach DeBoer, many questioned whether Alabama could sustain its recruiting dominance post-Saban. Those questions are rapidly vanishing. In just the last three months, Alabama has landed five 5-star prospects, including top-rated quarterback Dion Hartley from California and dominant edge rusher Quinton Rucker from Georgia. Hartley, in particular, turned heads when he flipped his commitment from Oregon to Alabama during a nationally televised ceremony — a recruiting win reminiscent of Saban flipping Landon Collins from LSU over a decade ago.
The momentum has been palpable. National recruiting analysts have vaulted Alabama’s 2025 class to No. 1 in the composite rankings, ahead of traditional powerhouses like Georgia, Ohio State, and Texas. More impressively, the Crimson Tide staff has begun building walls around in-state talent, with four of the top five Alabama prospects already pledged to the Tide — a trend that hasn’t been this dominant since the early 2010s.
“What’s so striking,” said 247Sports recruiting expert Taylor Whitman, “is how DeBoer and his staff have adapted Saban’s infrastructure but modernized the message. They’re still selling championships and NFL pipelines, but now it’s with a more personal, player-first energy. And recruits are responding.”
Finebaum went further, comparing DeBoer’s recent visits and camp showings to the precision and relentlessness of Saban’s heyday.
“There was a time when Saban would walk into a living room and the kid was ready to commit before he even sat down,” Finebaum said. “You’re starting to hear those kinds of stories about DeBoer now. It’s not just who he’s landing — it’s how he’s doing it.”
Still, questions remain. Saban didn’t just recruit — he developed, he schemed, he built legends. Can DeBoer take this wave of elite talent and turn it into another championship run?
For now, Alabama fans are content watching the tide rise again. If the past is any indication, the college football world may be on the verge of witnessing another crimson reign.
And if Finebaum’s instincts are right, it’s not just history repeating — it’s Alabama reclaiming its seat at the head of the college football table.
Let me know if you’d like this adapted into a column, social media thread, or TV segment-style script.
