Gordon Monson: Jake Retzlaff Expects to Suffer the Consequences of BYU’s Honor Code
In the ever-scrutinized world of BYU athletics, few situations have stirred as much attention in recent memory as the one surrounding quarterback Jake Retzlaff. In his latest column, longtime Salt Lake Tribune journalist Gordon Monson explores the implications of Retzlaff’s reported Honor Code violations and the larger cultural context within BYU’s unique institutional framework.
Retzlaff, who transferred to BYU with high hopes of leading the Cougars’ offense in the Big 12, now finds himself facing potential suspension or dismissal from the program. While exact details of the Honor Code violation remain confidential—as is BYU policy—the quarterback has acknowledged wrongdoing and, according to Monson’s reporting, is bracing himself for the consequences.
“Jake Retzlaff is not denying it,” Monson writes. “He knows the code. He knows the rules. And he knows he broke them.”
At the heart of this issue lies BYU’s Honor Code—a behavioral contract that all students, including athletes, must adhere to. Rooted in the values of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, the Honor Code forbids actions such as premarital sex, alcohol consumption, and dishonesty, and even governs aspects of appearance and dress. While upheld as a moral compass by many, it has long been a subject of national debate, especially when high-profile athletes are involved.
Monson highlights the moral complexity of the situation, noting that Retzlaff’s willingness to face discipline stands in contrast to the defiance often seen in college athletics. Rather than transferring quietly or issuing a carefully curated PR statement, Retzlaff reportedly chose to stay, cooperate, and accept whatever ruling comes his way.
“It’s rare in this era of image management and denial,” Monson writes, “but Retzlaff is owning it.”
The situation raises broader questions for BYU football, especially as it seeks to compete at the highest levels of collegiate athletics. Can a program with such strict behavioral expectations attract and retain top-tier talent? Is the Honor Code a barrier to success—or a bedrock that defines BYU’s identity?
For now, head coach Kalani Sitake and his staff remain tight-lipped. Retzlaff’s future with the program remains uncertain, but the story is far from over. Monson emphasizes that while punishment may be imminent, grace and redemption should also play a role in the process.
“This isn’t just about football,” Monson concludes. “It’s about a young man, a university’s principles, and a reckoning with personal responsibility.”
Regardless of how this unfolds, Jake Retzlaff’s situation serves as a reminder that being a student-athlete at BYU means playing by a different set of rules—rules that go far beyond the game.
