Assessing confidence in Sherrone Moore as Michigan Football’s head coach requires weighing his performance, context, and potential against the high expectations of a storied program. On a scale of 1 to 10, I’d rate confidence in Moore at a 6. This score reflects a blend of optimism for his long-term potential and acknowledgment of the challenges he’s faced in his early tenure, particularly in 2024, while considering the program’s trajectory and his ability to navigate adversity.
Moore’s first season as head coach in 2024, following Jim Harbaugh’s departure to the NFL, resulted in an 8-5 record, a respectable but not spectacular outcome for a team coming off a national championship. The Wolverines faced a brutal schedule, ranked among the toughest in college football, and lost key players like J.J. McCarthy, Blake Corum, and much of the offensive line—Moore’s area of expertise. Despite these challenges, Moore delivered signature wins, including a historic upset over No. 2 Ohio State as 20.5-point underdogs, marking Michigan’s fourth straight victory in the rivalry, and a bowl win against No. 11 Alabama. These victories, especially against Ohio State and Michigan State (the first Michigan coach to beat the Spartans in his debut since 1948), showcase Moore’s ability to rally his team in high-stakes moments, fostering optimism about his leadership.
However, the 2024 season exposed significant weaknesses that temper confidence. The offense, under Moore’s former play-calling purview, struggled mightily, ranking poorly in FBS metrics due to quarterback inconsistencies and an underperforming offensive line—surprising given Moore’s track record of coaching elite offensive lines that won the Joe Moore Award in 2021 and 2022. His decision to fire offensive coordinator Kirk Campbell after the season signals accountability, but it also raises questions about his initial staff choices. Additionally, the looming two-game suspension in 2025, tied to the Connor Stalions sign-stealing scandal, adds uncertainty. While self-imposed by Michigan, the NCAA could impose further penalties, potentially disrupting early-season momentum.
Moore’s recruiting prowess offers a strong case for confidence. Securing five-star quarterback Bryce Underwood, the No. 1 recruit in the 2025 class, is a coup that could stabilize the quarterback position long-term. His Midwest recruiting ties and energetic personality—described as a “connector” by former Oklahoma teammates—bode well for building a sustainable roster. Yet, the loss of five recruiting staffers in the 2025 offseason suggests potential instability in the program’s infrastructure, which Moore must address to maintain recruiting momentum.
Fan and analyst sentiment, as seen on platforms like X, is polarized. Some praise Moore’s resilience, citing his ability to turn a 5-5 season into 8-5 with key victories, while others argue he was “born on third base,” inheriting a championship program only to oversee a significant drop-off. His lack of head-coaching experience before 2024 is a valid concern, but examples like Nick Saban and Kirby Smart, who overcame shaky first seasons, suggest Moore could grow into the role.
Ultimately, confidence in Moore hinges on his ability to fix offensive woes, stabilize the staff, and navigate NCAA challenges. His 2024 performance shows promise but not yet mastery. A 6 reflects cautious optimism: Moore has the tools but must prove he can wield them consistently to restore Michigan’s elite status.
