Quarterbacks who transfer from Group of Five (G5) programs to Power Four (P4) schools can absolutely find success — but the results vary widely depending on fit, coaching, system, and individual talent. Here’s a breakdown of the trend and how it has played out:
—
✅ Notable Success Stories
1. Michael Penix Jr. (Indiana → Washington)
While Indiana is technically a Power Five team, his rise at Washington after injuries and inconsistency was dramatic. He led Washington to the CFP title game and became a top NFL Draft pick.
2. Bo Nix (Auburn → Oregon)
Originally at a Power Five school, Nix transformed his career after transferring and became a Heisman contender.
3. Bailey Zappe (Houston Baptist → Western Kentucky → NFL)
Zappe lit up defenses after moving from a smaller G5 school to a more competitive mid-major, eventually getting drafted into the NFL.
4. JT Daniels (USC → Georgia → West Virginia → Rice)
Although inconsistent, Daniels showed flashes of P4-level play even while bouncing through different programs.
—
⚠️ Common Challenges
Speed of the Game: P4 defenses are faster, more complex, and more aggressive.
System Fit: A QB who thrived in a pass-happy or run-pass-option (RPO) system may struggle if the new offense doesn’t suit their strengths.
Depth Chart Battles: P4 programs typically have higher-rated recruits, so transfers face more intense competition.
—
📊 Recent Trends
The transfer portal has made these moves increasingly common. Many coaches are now more willing to take experienced G5 QBs than risk a true freshman. In 2023-24, more than 10 G5-to-P4 QBs started games for Power programs.
—
🏈 Bottom Line
Yes, G5-to-P4 QB transfers can succeed — but success often hinges on:
Coaching and development
Offensive system fit
Opportunity to start early
Maturity and leadership
For many, it’s the seco
