If BYU makes a final decision to move on from starting quarterback Jake Retzlaff amid ongoing legal issues, the program will face significant implications both on and off the field.
Legal Context
Retzlaff is currently facing a civil lawsuit filed in Salt Lake County, Utah, accusing him of sexual assault, battery, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. The incident allegedly occurred in November 2023 at his residence in Provo, Utah. Retzlaff’s attorney has declared him “factually innocent” and intends to prove this in court. BYU has acknowledged awareness of the case and affirmed it would follow Title IX procedures.
Potential Quarterback Replacements
Should BYU decide to part ways with Retzlaff, the quarterback position would likely be filled by one of the following players:
McCae Hillstead: A redshirt sophomore transfer from Utah State, Hillstead started four games as a true freshman in 2023 and earned Academic All-Mountain West honors. He has been noted for his leadership and quick decision-making abilities.
Treyson Bourguet: A redshirt junior transfer from Western Michigan, Bourguet has demonstrated a strong arm and mobility during practices. Offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick mentioned that both Hillstead and Bourguet have shown improvement, with no clear separation between them as of the end of spring camp.
A recent fan poll indicated a clear preference for Hillstead as Retzlaff’s successor, suggesting strong support from the BYU community.
Impact on the 2025 Season
Retzlaff played a pivotal role in BYU’s successful 2024 season, leading the team to an 11–2 record and an Alamo Bowl victory. His departure would necessitate adjustments in offensive strategy and could impact team dynamics.
Despite the potential setback, BYU’s coaching staff has expressed confidence in the depth and talent of the quarterback room. Both Hillstead and Bourguet have Division I experience, and the team is prepared to adapt as needed.
As the situation develops, BYU will continue to monitor legal proceedings and make decisions that align with university policies and the best interests of the football program.
For more insights on BYU’s quarterback situation, you may find the following vi
