BYU Football Faces Uphill Battle Amid Transition Turbulence
Brigham Young University (BYU) football is navigating a challenging chapter in its storied history. With the program’s recent move to the Big 12 Conference, the Cougars have entered a new era marked by increased competition, growing pains, and the pressing need for rapid adaptation. Once a dominant force among independents, BYU is now finding that the road in a Power Five conference is steep, with few easy victories and many hard lessons.
The transition from independence to conference play brings numerous advantages—better exposure, stronger recruiting opportunities, and more lucrative financial arrangements—but it also introduces a much higher level of week-to-week competition. In the Big 12, every game presents a formidable opponent, with little margin for error. BYU’s coaching staff and players are still adjusting to this reality. The physicality, speed, and depth of Big 12 teams have proven to be a stark contrast to BYU’s previous schedules, which included a mix of high-profile games and more manageable matchups.
One of the most significant hurdles has been depth. While BYU has talented starters, the grind of a Power Five schedule requires second- and third-string players who can step in without a dramatic drop in performance. Injuries and fatigue are inevitable over the course of a season, and without deep rosters, teams can quickly falter. BYU is learning this the hard way, as injuries have exposed gaps that were less apparent in their independent days.
Moreover, recruiting has taken on heightened importance. To compete consistently in the Big 12, BYU must attract athletes capable of standing toe-to-toe with top-tier programs. This means investing more in facilities, NIL (name, image, and likeness) opportunities, and overall program development. While BYU has strong traditions and a loyal fanbase, it is still working to catch up to its new conference peers in these critical areas.
The coaching staff, led by Kalani Sitake, has faced criticism and praise alike as they navigate this transition. Sitake has been a steadying presence, but the increased scrutiny and pressure to produce results in the Big 12 have made the job more difficult. Adjusting schemes, managing player morale, and making smart in-game decisions are now under a brighter spotlight than ever before.
Despite the struggles, there is optimism within the program. Transition periods are rarely smooth, and growing pains are part of the process. BYU’s administration has shown commitment to supporting the football team’s needs, and the players are gaining valuable experience every week. While wins may be harder to come by in the short term, the long-term outlook remains promising—provided the Cougars can recruit effectively, stay healthy, and continue to evolve.
The journey ahead is demanding, but BYU has the foundation and culture to eventually thrive in the Big 12. The road may be steep now, but with resilience and smart leadership, the Cougars can climb to new heights in their new football home.
