Four Coaches the Dallas Cowboys Should Have Considered Instead of Brian Schottenheimer
The Dallas Cowboys have made a significant decision regarding their leadership by promoting offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer to head coach. However, this move has sparked widespread skepticism among fans and analysts alike. Many in the fanbase are already questioning the team’s direction for the upcoming season, as Schottenheimer’s track record and potential to elevate the team’s performance remain under scrutiny.
The decision to part ways with Mike McCarthy, who had his share of ups and downs, was a bold one. Yet, the selection of Schottenheimer as his successor has left many wondering if this was truly the best option available. Based on this choice, it almost feels as though Dallas might have been better off sticking with McCarthy rather than taking a gamble on Schottenheimer.
While Schottenheimer has experience in the NFL as both a coordinator and coach, his tenure has been marked by inconsistency. Critics argue that his offensive schemes, while serviceable, often lack creativity and adaptability—key traits necessary for a team looking to contend for a championship. Given these concerns, it’s worth exploring alternative candidates the Cowboys could have pursued. Here are four head coaches who might have been better options to lead America’s Team into the future.
1. Eric Bieniemy
Eric Bieniemy, the offensive coordinator for the Kansas City Chiefs, has been a perennial head coaching candidate for several years. With a proven track record of working alongside Andy Reid to create one of the most dynamic offenses in NFL history, Bieniemy has been instrumental in the development of Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs’ success. His ability to craft innovative game plans and maximize the potential of his players could have been exactly what the Cowboys needed to unlock their offensive talent.
2. Sean Payton
Although Sean Payton ultimately chose to return to coaching with the Denver Broncos, his name had long been linked to the Cowboys. Payton, who served as the head coach of the New Orleans Saints for over a decade, has a reputation for being one of the brightest offensive minds in the league. With a Super Bowl victory under his belt and a history of getting the most out of his rosters, Payton’s experience and expertise could have been a game-changer for Dallas.
3. DeMeco Ryans
DeMeco Ryans, the former defensive coordinator for the San Francisco 49ers, has quickly risen through the coaching ranks thanks to his impressive work in developing one of the NFL’s top defenses. Now the head coach of the Houston Texans, Ryans’ leadership qualities, defensive acumen, and ability to connect with players make him an intriguing option. Given the Cowboys’ already strong defensive foundation, Ryans could have taken their defense to an elite level while fostering a culture of accountability and resilience.
4. Dan Quinn
While the Cowboys opted to promote from within by elevating Schottenheimer, they could have looked no further than their own defensive coordinator, Dan Quinn. Quinn’s impact on the Cowboys’ defense has been profound, transforming it into one of the most formidable units in the league. With prior head coaching experience that includes leading the Atlanta Falcons to a Super Bowl appearance, Quinn’s familiarity with the team and ability to inspire his players made him a logical candidate for the job.
Final Thoughts
The Cowboys’ decision to promote Brian Schottenheimer as their head coach has undeniably raised eyebrows, with many questioning whether it was the right move for a franchise striving to return to Super Bowl glory. While Schottenheimer will have the opportunity to prove his doubters wrong, it’s hard to ignore the wealth of coaching talent available during this hiring cycle.
From offensive innovators like Eric Bieniemy and Sean Payton to defensive masterminds like DeMeco Ryans and Dan Quinn, the Cowboys had several compelling options to consider. Only time will tell if Schottenheimer can rise to the occasion and lead Dallas to success, but for now, the decision remains a polarizing one among fans and analysts.
