When the Carolina Panthers unveiled their quarter-century Mount Rushmore, fans celebrated the recognition of some of the franchise’s most iconic figures. However, the announcement also sparked debate about who was left out. While the chosen honorees deserved their place, three notable names stood out as surprising omissions, raising questions about how history should weigh impact, legacy, and fan connection.
First is wide receiver Steve Beuerlein, a player who may not have had the long tenure of others but delivered one of the most memorable quarterback seasons in franchise history. In 1999, he set multiple records, including passing yards, and gave the Panthers their first taste of elite quarterback play. His contributions often fly under the radar, but his role in putting Carolina on the map can’t be ignored.
Then there’s linebacker Jon Beason, who for several years was the heart of the defense. Though his career was shortened by injuries, his dominance in the late 2000s was undeniable. A three-time Pro Bowler and respected locker room leader, Beason bridged the era between Sam Mills’ influence and Luke Kuechly’s dominance. His absence on the Mount Rushmore is surprising given his status as one of the team’s most feared defenders during his prime.
Lastly, running back Stephen Davis deserves mention. A key figure in the Panthers’ 2003 Super Bowl run, Davis transformed the offense with his physical running style. His ability to carry the team on his back, especially during the playoffs, cemented his place in franchise lore. Without Davis, the Panthers likely don’t reach their first championship game.
While Mount Rushmore selections always spark debate, these three players’ contributions make them difficult to overlook. Their omission serves as a reminder of how deep and rich the Panthers’ 25-year history tr
uly is.
